Issue 001November 16, 2026

Maju Forest and Gillman Lose 1,200 Flats. The Plan Didn't Blink.

Maju Forest and Gillman Lose 1,200 Flats. The Plan Didn't Blink. — Roncasa Singapore property analysis

HDB cut about 1,200 homes from the Maju Forest and Gillman Barracks plans, and the revised plan still stands at about 11,000 homes over the next decade. That is not a retreat. That is the same ambition, folded into a smaller footprint.

Homes trimmed
Fewer homes, same decade-long plan
1,200 fewer: 400 Maju Forest, 800 Gillman
Maju Forest greenery
Nearly half the site now stays green
45% kept, up from 35% (about 10ha vs 8ha)
Gillman greenery
Green share jumps by half
60% kept, up from 40% (about 12ha vs 8ha)
Public pushback
Loud enough to redraw the map
About 9,500 feedback submissions, 50,000+ petition signatures

What's actually happening

The revised plans follow environmental studies on both sites, a heritage study for Gillman Barracks, and the public feedback that came after the 10 July announcement. At Maju Forest, around 10ha (45%) of the site will now be retained as greenery, up from roughly 8ha (35%). The extra green sits at the southern part of the site, which widens the green area along the Clementi Nature Corridor. At Gillman Barracks, the green share rises from 40% to about 60%, around 12ha, with more of the forest around the hillock kept and the ecological corridor along Lock Road and Malan Road widened.

The housing count shifts accordingly. Maju Forest drops by about 400 flats to roughly 4,000 public homes. Gillman Barracks drops by about 800 units to around 7,000 homes, of which about 5,500 are HDB flats. HDB says these are estimates from broad planning assumptions, and the real count only firms up at detailed design stage.

Here is the part I'd underline. HDB also said it intends to use the remaining development area efficiently, for example by building taller blocks. Less sprawl, more height. The 1,200 fewer homes and the 11,000 total are both the revised estimates, so I wouldn't read the taller blocks as winning any homes back. The housing mix and launch dates have not been announced yet, so what the blocks will actually look and feel like is still an open question.

The sites at a glance

Site What changed What it signals
Maju Forest (Sunset Way) About 4,000 public homes, down 400. Greenery 35% to 45%. A smaller footprint, with a wider green area along the Clementi Nature Corridor.
Gillman Barracks About 7,000 homes (around 5,500 HDB), down 800. Greenery 40% to 60%. The bigger cut. More forest around the hillock is kept, and the north-south corridor is widened.
Both sites combined Around 11,000 homes over the next decade. Supply intent holds. The timeline is a decade, not a launch next quarter.
NParks role A significant portion of greenery to be safeguarded as nature parks. The green is being locked in, not just left over.

What resale prices look like in two established HDB towns

Neither site will have a flat to sell for years, so there is no price to quote for them. The source doesn't say which existing HDB town each site sits closest to, so I won't pretend to map them. What I can give you is a reference point for how resale is pricing in two established towns, Bukit Merah and Clementi, using URA data. Across the records I pulled, Bukit Merah has 900 resale transactions at a median of about $795,000, with 217 of them at $1 million or more. Clementi has 483 transactions at a median of about $620,000, with 97 at $1 million or more.

By flat type, in the same URA data (records run up to Nov 2026): Bukit Merah 4-room flats show a median near $945,000 across 201 transactions, and 5-room flats a median of $1,000,000 across 97. Clementi 4-room flats show about $847,000 across 81 transactions, and 5-room flats about $1,000,000 across 36. Average psf is around $903 for Bukit Merah 4-room and $841 for Clementi 4-room; for 5-room it is about $817 in Bukit Merah and $869 in Clementi. I'd read the psf gaps with care, since psf alone doesn't tell you why two towns differ.

What Ron is watching
  • If HDB announces the housing mix soon — that is the first real clue to who these homes are built for. Until then, any claim about the target buyer is a guess.
  • If the taller blocks become the headline feature — then what you get from the greenery depends on which blocks and which floors face it. Ask for the site plan before you fall for the pitch.
  • If launch dates land early in the decade — resale owners in nearby towns face competing new supply sooner. If they land late, the supply worry is mostly noise today.
  • If the final unit count slides again at detailed design — HDB itself said these are broad estimates. The 1,200 may not be the last number to move.

Who this actually affects

Who What it means What to do now
First-time couples waiting for new HDB supply in the south or west About 9,500 public homes are still planned across both sites, with launch dates yet to be announced. Don't plan around these sites yet. Keep applying in the current BTO rounds and check your income and grant eligibility.
Resale owners near the two sites New supply is a decade-long story, not an overnight one. Don't sell on fear. If you are selling anyway, price against recent actual deals on your own block.
Upgraders weighing a 5-room resale against waiting In the URA data above, the 5-room median is about $1,000,000 in both Bukit Merah and Clementi. Compare a live 5-room resale against waiting for new supply. A decade is long if your family is growing now.
Nature and heritage lovers More forest around the hillock, a widened corridor, nature-park safeguards. Wait for the site plans and the housing mix. Which blocks face the green is what will matter to you.

Ron's read

I'll be honest: this is the rarest kind of policy story, where the public pushed and the map actually changed. About 7,200 submissions on Maju Forest, 2,300 on Gillman, petitions past 50,000 signatures, and the green share moved from 35% to 45% at one site and 40% to 60% at the other. If you've ever felt that big plans in Singapore are sealed before you hear about them, this is a case where the consultation had teeth. That alone is worth a pause.

But the trade-off is real. Fewer acres to build on, a decade-long plan, and HDB saying it will build taller blocks on what's left: that is a different kind of living. It could suit the person who would happily trade ground-level space for a view of treetops, and it won't suit someone who wants a quiet low-rise estate feel. We won't know which until HDB shares the mix and the layouts. My view: treat Maju Forest and Gillman Barracks as a long-dated story, not a next-year plan. If you need a home in the next few years, work with what is live today, and keep these two sites as a bonus on the horizon.

If you're weighing a resale against waiting for new supply, I can pull the last 6 months of actual transacted resale prices for your specific block and flat type so you can see exactly where the bar sits today.

HDB decisions involve more moving parts than the headline suggests: upgrading timeline, CPF usage, loan limits, resale levy. If you want a clear picture of where you stand, let's map it out.

📲 WhatsApp Ronnie directly | Book a consultation

(source)